Thursday, 6 December 2007

so far...

The boxing match previously posted is an extract from a website/blog . It had been written by an angry young man, who had just been rejected for a job interview because of not having enough experience. It is closely related to the idea of what we ("we" being our group) are thinking about when we think about the differences between Knowledge and Experience. The angry young man goes on to explain that another applicant with more experience got the job and not him, I can't help but sympathise with the angry young man. The amounts of times myself and my peers have been rejected for a job because of lack of experience. Where exactly are we meant to get this experience from if no one will employ us in the first place? The angry young man may have just as much knowledge as the other applicant that got the job perhaps more, but for some reason the more experienced seemed to have pipped him to the post. Was this the right thing to do? Is experience better to have than knowledge?

I mean, I guess it's happened to everybody at some point in your life, where you've been made to feel small, because somebody else has learnt something you don't know and is blatantly flaunting this fact, or when you have had to lie to cover up the fact you didn't know a certain fact that for some reason everybody else seems to know.
My friend was in a bar and these 'old' punks with Ramone's (Topshop favourite punk band) leather jackets on and The Ramone's tattoos were pointing at my friends t-shirt, which happened to be a Black Flag t-shirt (for those of you who don't know Black Flag were a hardcore punk band from the early 80's). So these old punks come over to my friend and start grilling them about this t-shirt, saying things like "Your not old enough to like Black Flag", and "I bet you don't even know who they are!" etc etc more derogatory comments made towards my friends youth and apparent inexperience. They continue on to ask, "Do you like The Ramone's?" my friend says "Yeah, they're alright. Don't really like them that much though." To a response of "Don't like them that much? Yeah they only made like 41 records and were the most influential punk bands of all time blah blah blah..." so my friend retorted with "Well I'm more into Minor Threat and Youth of Today, that kind of thing" (some more hardcore punk bands from late 70's early 80's) and the old punks seem slightly off put, that this inexperienced youth has some knowledge that he doesn't seem to have. "Oh yeah" he says, "Their that T - Total edge thing..."? And my friend just says "You mean straight edge?" and walks away. Ok not the best example but it shows that even though these old punks were trying to show off their experience, it shows you can have a lot of experience and still not know that much. In this case it seems that experience isn't necessarily better than knowledge. Some people only seem to have small amount of experience in one tiny area. This is where knowledge can have the upper hand, however it just depends on how widely this knowledge is spread.


This extract from the blog we created, it just outlines why Wikipedia knowledge isn't such a great source of information all the time.
" "
When marking essays now, examiners don't give credit to references from Wikipedia because they may not be factual information.
(So we're trying to stay away from that website...for now.)

But does experience really prove the better option over knowledge or is it just the best man...or woman for the job?
In terms of graphic design or art and creativity in general, in this day and age, where nearly everybody owns a digital camera, and can take great looking photographs, where everybody and their Mums knows what Helvetica is and create great ideas. Are artists being made redundant by the general public? Do artists have to 'dumb down' their work to make it easier to digest for the public? Or is that what graphic designers and advertisers do? Make "hi" art more accessible to everybody?
Is fine art Shredded Wheat and graphic design Shredded Wheat Bite-size? Porridge vs. Ready Break??
My point is: does knowledge or experience matter at all, when anyone can create perfectly good art? Or is there a distinct line where the input of knowledge and experience in used?


So, is there a way to come to a practical conclusion to whether knowledge or experience, is more valid or valuable than the other in Graphic Design or Art and creative practices? Well on a small scale we think that you can come to some kind of conclusion.
We have developed two experiments that we can conduct easily. The first being, as I previously mentioned, a lot of people nowadays seem to own and be quite proficient with a digital camera. So the first experiment is going to be on photography. It will have three parts (convenient that we have three people in our group).
We shall separate ourselves into: experience, knowledge, and clueless.
All of us will photograph one subject or object. One of us will have to have used the equipment before and has basically had previous experience in the studio and with lighting etc.
Another of us will read all the same information from books the internet with no practical experience, in other words knowledge.
And the remaining experimenter, will do neither of these, no previous experience or knowledge.

The second experiment will involve drawing/mark making possibly the most primitive and simplest forms of image making. It will involve all of us again, and one subject to draw from. However this time we will all get a chance at approaching the idea from every angle. We will have three stations, one where the subject is being drawn from still life (the experience of actually seeing it), another station where the subject will be drawn from a photograph (the knowledge of what it looks like) and the final one where the person drawing it will just be told what the subject they are drawing is. Then we will all rotate and try it in a different way. And a final go at the remaining approach not yet attempted, this way we have more evidence to back up our conclusion. We thought it would be best for the person drawing the subject/object from real life to pick what we are drawing and then take a picture of it, and give the photograph of the subject to the next person and then tell the last person what it is we will be drawing.

No comments: